Canada Featured

Manitoba NDP Faces Allegations Over Provincial Nominee Program

Manitoba NDP Faces Allegations
Photograph : Copyright - ©2011 Robert David Linsdell, CC BY 4.0

Alleged Threats by Manitoba’s Immigration Minister

In a shocking revelation at the Manitoba Legislature, the Official Opposition has accused the New Democratic Party (NDP) of threatening individuals protesting changes to the province’s provincial nominee program. The Progressive Conservatives presented a redacted letter during a heated question period, alleging that Labour and Immigration Minister Malaya Marcelino threatened to delay immigration draws as a means of silencing protesters. The accusations have stirred calls for an investigation and even a resignation, as they suggest an infringement on citizens’ rights.

Permanent Residency Dreams Hindered

One of the key components fuelling these allegations is the growing concern among skilled workers in Manitoba. These workers claim they are systematically overlooked for permanent residency due to the provincial government’s refocus on applicants with familial ties within the province. This shift in priorities has caused anxiety among over 700 newcomers, many of whom are on expiring work permits, desperately seeking to secure their future in Manitoba.

Charter Rights and Political Backlash

The situation escalates as the PCs demand Malaya Marcelino’s resignation, underlining that her alleged actions contradict principles enshrined in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The controversy revolves around the fundamental right to protest, with allegations implying government interference and intimidation against those exercising this right. The call for an independent investigation signifies the severity of concerns raised by opposition members, who stand in solidarity with worried Manitobans facing uncertain futures.

Reforms Spark Outcry from Skilled Migrants

As Yatin Joshi and peers represent a group of newly arrived migrants, their actions signify a plea for justice. The labour market’s evolving dynamics due to altered criteria in the provincial nominee program lead to skilled workers feeling sidelined. With the federal cap on nominees for Manitoba compounding issues, many individuals are now left pondering their permanency prospects while grappling with worries about being uprooted from the community they hoped to call home.

Tensions Rise Over Manitoba Provincial Nominee Program Allegations

In what has become a heated issue, Marcelino vehemently refuted allegations made by the PC, stating, “That is completely false. I have never threatened folks.” This statement emerges amidst recent complaints from newcomers regarding the Manitoba Provincial Nominee Program, suggesting it unfairly disadvantages those without family in the province.

The Provincial Nominee Program

The Manitoba Provincial Nominee Program facilitates the entry of foreign workers into the province to address specific labour shortages. It operates on a selective basis wherein candidates express their interest and are then invited to apply. Their selection is not left to chance but is governed by a strategic ranking scale that considers numerous elements.

Recent Changes and Their Impact

Under new directions by the NDP government, preference has been accorded to skilled workers with relatives already residing in Manitoba. The government believes this policy will enhance retention rates of these newcomers. Yet, an unintended consequence has been a reduction in numbers for applicants lacking provincial family ties, sparking criticism and resulting in protests outside the legislature and at the program’s office on Notre Dame Avenue.

Protests and Government Response

Critics have voiced their dissent through several demonstrations including a major one on April 4 and subsequent protests targeting the program’s administrative center. Post-demonstration discussions saw Premier Wab Kinew engage with skilled workers aspiring for Permanent Residency Manitoba. Marcelino too has been active, planning to lobby for work permit extensions federally—a practice halted post COVID-19—announcing, “We are working so hard to make sure that these folks can stay in the country.”

Alleged Threats to Protesters

In what has emerged as a contentious issue, the Liberals have accused the government of unethical behaviour. According to a letter received by the Progressive Conservatives (PCs), a minister allegedly warned that “continued protests would result in another four-month suspension of draws” in the skilled workers and international education streams, casting shadows over the Manitoba Provincial Nominee Program.

Interim Liberal Leader Cindy Lamoureux expressed her concerns over this development. She relayed an instance where a skilled worker, with initial plans to organize a protest, retreated in fear following the supposed threat. She emphasized that such threats are antithetical to democratic principles and condemned the idea that peaceful protests could affect one’s chance of Permanent Residency in Manitoba.

Skilled Workers Union Refutes Allegation

While speculation circulates, Yatin Joshi, chairman of International Students and Skilled Workers Union Manitoba, provided an alternate narrative. He attested that at no point during their meeting had any threat been made. Instead, he stated that Flor Marcelino engaged constructively and implied impending positive news which diffused their motivation to protest.

Processing Delays Acknowledged

The current backlog in the Manitoba Provincial Nominee Program has been acknowledged by officials as well. Marcelino cited ‘unprecedented interest’ from applicants combined with staffing challenges as primary reasons for recent delays. The official response included assurance that an increase in staffing has occurred to deal with application processing.

Manitoba’s Newcomers Face Judgment

Joshi’s Experience with the Manitoba Provincial Nominee Program

Among the recent arrivals in Manitoba eager to build a life is Joshi, an immigrant from India who argues against the negative judgments newcomers often face due to the actions of certain individuals. Having moved to Manitoba after completing his business administration diploma in Quebec, Joshi regards Manitoba as a place that fosters growth and affordability, particularly when it comes to housing. Yet, he feels that residents like him are unfairly evaluated based on the presence of familial ties within the province rather than their individual merit and intention to settle long-term.

Retention Struggles and Future Hopes

Although Manitoba uses tax filings to track immigrant retention over five years, recent patterns show a decrease in retention rates since 2014. As of 2020 data, the rate stood at 67.7 percent. Amidst these statistics are immigrants like Joshi who have integrated into the community through employment and personal connections, aspiring for stability that leads toward homeownership and Permanent Residency Manitoba.

Challenges Ahead: Temporary Permits Nearing Expiry

On another front, Jasica Tung also from India and currently a collections clerk, faces uncertainty with her work permit expiring soon. Despite her education and progress made in Manitoba, options seem bleak without a clear pathway to extend her stay or obtain permanent residency—highlighting a common struggle among newcomers who wish to call Manitoba their lasting home.

Call for Renewal of Manitoba Nominee Draws amid Permit Concerns

The Manitoba Provincial Nominee Program (MPNP), designed to welcome newcomers and bolster the province’s economy, is facing a call for change as federal work permits expire. During the crisis period, the government extended work permits for up to 18 months, a policy that has seen its end. This cessation has spiked urgency for many immigrants to gain permanent residency in Manitoba.

A coalition of concerned stakeholders penned a letter to Minister Marcelino, pressing for the reintroduction of provincial nominee draws, specifically targeting individuals in high-demand occupations. Their advocacy underscores the need for such measures to offset the implications of those soon-to-be-lapsed permits.

Proposed Adjustments to Eligibility Criteria for Enhanced Retention

In an effort to enhance retention rates in Manitoba, the group’s letter advocates a revision of the eligibility conditions for one branch of the MPNP. It suggests considering international students not currently residing in the province but who have lived in Manitoba for at least two years, intensifying from the current one-year requirement. This recommendation aims to attract genuinely interested candidates dedicated to contributing to and settling within the community.

Labour Shortage and Family-First Prioritization

The persistent labour shortage plagues local businesses as Joshi expresses concern over the shift in governmental focus towards family-based applicants under Permanent Residency Manitoba policies. The group argues this shift could aggravate existing workforce deficits. Many employers have reached out to provincial authorities requesting modifications to the MPNP, seeking means to retain their workforce amid policy shifts.

Although Minister Marcelino was unavailable for commentary, her office relayed her appreciation for such dialogues. The official statement reaffirmed that forging strong familial ties is believed to encourage newcomers’ long-term residence in Manitoba. The office highlighted distressing statistics revealing that Manitoba is grappling with its highest rates of outmigration in two decades.

Joshi and his peers met with NDP MLA Mintu Sandhu for what was described as constructive discussions on these vital issues. Strengthening their resolve, they aspire to convey their urgent concerns and recommendations directly to Minister Marcelino’s purview, emphasizing the critical nature of these discussions on both immigrants’ future and Manitoba’s economic stability.

Related posts

Landed Immigrants from Africa and Asia see Highest Employment Rates in Canada


PERM: Foundation of US Immigration’s Labor Certification


Canada’s New IRCC Policy Clearing Up Visitor and Super Visa Backlog

× How can I help you?